Mechanisms underlying lateral force applied to a PDC cutter on a PDC drill bit during rotary rock breaking

Authors

• WEI Jiusen, MOE Key Laboratory of Petroleum Engineering, China University of Petroleum (Beijing), Beijing 102249, ChinaFollow
• HAN Xin, Zhengzhou New Asia Superhard Material Composite Co., Ltd., Zhengzhou 450001, China
• LIU Wei, MOE Key Laboratory of Petroleum Engineering, China University of Petroleum (Beijing), Beijing 102249, ChinaFollow
• GAO Deli, MOE Key Laboratory of Petroleum Engineering, China University of Petroleum (Beijing), Beijing 102249, ChinaFollow

Abstract

Objective To improve the rock-breaking efficiency and durability of drill bits in the theoretical research on the optimal design of drill bits, the key is to systematically reveal both the rock-breaking mechanisms of polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) cutters and the characteristics of forces applied to them. Methods Existing studies on rock breaking using a single PDC cutter generally adopt a linear or approximately linear cutting mode while neglecting the impacts of the radius of gyration. To address this issue, this study conducted experiments on cylindrical granite samples using a laboratory experimental setting for single-cutter rock breaking. With cutting depth and the radius of gyration as variables, this study systematically investigated the rotary rock-breaking process under small radii of gyration using a PDC cutter on a scale of a drill bit diameter of 215.9 mm. Accordingly, the impacts of the radius of gyration on both the rock-breaking process of a PDC cutter and the applied forces were identified. Furthermore, the conventional method for calculating mechanical specific energy was optimized by indirectly considering the impacts of the lateral force on rock-breaking efficiency. Based on this, the impacts of the radius of gyration on the rock-breaking efficiency of a PDC cutter were quantitatively evaluated. Results and Conclusions The results indicate that the radius of gyration exerted a significant impact on the lateral and normal forces applied to the PDC cutter. Specifically, a smaller radius of gyration corresponded to a larger lateral force, which increased the normal force in turn. The morphological analysis of rock cutting traces reveals that during the rotary rock breaking under a small radius of gyration, rock spalling on the outer edge of cutting traces created large cuttings and crushed pits. Consequently, only the inner cutting edge of the PDC cutter came into contact with rocks, inducing an amplification effect of lateral force. The analytical results of the energy consumption in rock breaking show that a smaller radius of gyration was associated with a higher energy consumption of the PDC cutter. For a PDC drill bit, increasing the conical surface angle at the bit center can reduce the rotational curvature differences between the cutting edges on both sides of the PDC cutter. This helps reduce the adverse impacts of the radius of gyration on the rock-breaking efficiency. The results of this study account partially for the limited rock-breaking efficiency and durability of PDC cutter at the center of a drill bit, providing a theoretical reference for the optimal design of PDC bits.

Keywords

polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) drill bit, PDC cutter, radius of gyration, asymmetric cutting, lateral force, rock-breaking efficiency

DOI

10.12363/issn.1001-1986.25.12.0931

Recommended Citation

WEI Jiusen, HAN Xin, LIU Wei, et al. (2026) "Mechanisms underlying lateral force applied to a PDC cutter on a PDC drill bit during rotary rock breaking," Coal Geology & Exploration: Vol. 54: Iss. 4, Article 21.
DOI: 10.12363/issn.1001-1986.25.12.0931
Available at: https://cge.researchcommons.org/journal/vol54/iss4/21

Reference

[1] 刘岩生,张佳伟,黄洪春. 中国深层–超深层钻完井关键技术及发展方向[J]. 石油学报,2024,45(1):312−324

LIU Yansheng,ZHANG Jiawei,HUANG Hongchun. Key technologies and development direction for deep and ultra–deep drilling and completion in China[J]. Acta Petrolei Sinica,2024,45(1):312−324

[2] 孙金声,刘伟,王庆,等. 万米超深层油气钻完井关键技术面临挑战与发展展望[J]. 钻采工艺,2024,47(2):1−9

SUN Jinsheng,LIU Wei,WANG Qing,et al. Challenges and development prospects of oil and gas drilling and completion in myriametric deep formation in China[J]. Drilling & Production Technology,2024,47(2):1−9

[3] 刘维,高德利. PDC钻头研究现状与发展趋势[J]. 前瞻科技,2023,2(2):168−178

LIU Wei,GAO Deli. Research status and development trends of polycrystalline diamond compact bits[J]. Science and Technology Foresight,2023,2(2):168−178

[4] 高德利,刘维,万绪新,等. PDC钻头钻井提速关键影响因素研究[J]. 石油钻探技术,2023,51(4):20−34

GAO Deli,LIU Wei,WAN Xuxin,et al. Study on key factors influencing the ROP improvement of PDC bits[J]. Petroleum Drilling Techniques,2023,51(4):20−34

[5] CHEN Shilin,KHLEFAT Y,CLEBOSKI C,et al. A new method of backup–cutter layout to extend bit life without sacrificing rate of penetration[J]. SPE Drilling & Completion,2018,33(2):115−129.

[6] EL–GAYAR M，HORRA H，MAOUCHE Z. Innovative cutter layout technology minimized PDC bit vibrations with RSS tool and helped in placing borehole accurately while drilling in tight reservoirs[C]//Abu Dhabi International Petroleum Exhibition & Conference. Abu Dhabi：Society of Petroleum Engineers，2016：SPE–183030–MS.

[7] 陈晗,李欣龙,史怀忠,等. 布齿方式对PDC齿破岩特性影响[J]. 中国石油大学学报(自然科学版),2024,48(5):83−90

CHEN Han,LI Xinlong,SHI Huaizhong,et al. Rock breaking characteristics under different cutter arrangements on PDC bits[J]. Journal of China University of Petroleum (Edition of Natural Science),2024,48(5):83−90

[8] HUANG Anlong,WEI Guo,ZOU Yun,et al. Numerical simulation of rock breaking by PDC cutter with finite–discrete–infinite element method[J]. Geoenergy Science and Engineering,2023,225:211725.

[9] 田丰,杨迎新,任海涛,等. PDC钻头切削齿工作区域及切削量的分析理论和计算方法[J]. 钻采工艺,2009,32(2):51−53

TIAN Feng,YANG Yingxin,REN Haitao,et al. Analytical theory and computational method of contact area and cutting volume of PDC bit cutters[J]. Drilling & Production Technology,2009,32(2):51−53

[10] WU Zebing,YUAN Ruofei,ZHANG Wenxi,et al. Numerical simulation and field test of a PDC bit with mixed cutter arrangement to break non–homogeneous granite[J]. Applied Sciences,2023,13(16):9133.

[11] WEI Jiusen,LIU Wei,GAO Deli. Effect of cutter shape on the resistance of PDC cutters against tip impacts[J]. SPE Journal,2022,27(5):3035−3050.

[12] WEI Jiusen,LIU Wei,GAO Deli. Mechanism analysis and mathematical modeling of brittle failure in rock cutting with a single sharp cylinder–shaped PDC cutter[J]. SPE Journal,2024,29(2):651−669.

[13] 胡莉,况雨春,龙伟,等. 宽刃齿微钻头设计及破岩机理研究[J]. 石油机械,2024,52(11):1−11

HU Li,KUANG Yuchun,LONG Wei,et al. Design and rock–breaking mechanism of micro–bit with wide edge cutter[J]. China Petroleum Machinery,2024,52(11):1−11

[14] 赫文豪,李欣龙,张润青,等. 基于岩屑形貌分形特征的PDC齿破岩比功评估模型[J]. 工程设计学报,2025,32(1):23−31

HE Wenhao,LI Xinlong,ZHANG Runqing,et al. Evaluation model of rock–breaking specific energy for PDC cutter based on fractal characteristics of rock cutting morphology[J]. Chinese Journal of Engineering Design,2025,32(1):23−31

[15] 刘忠,赵航,李劲,等. 屋脊齿破岩生成岩屑特性研究[J]. 石油矿场机械,2022,51(4):12−21

LIU Zhong,ZHAO Hang,LI Jin,et al. Study on cuttings generated by ridge cutter[J]. Oil Field Equipment,2022,51(4):12−21

[16] SHAO Fangyuan,LIU Wei,GAO Deli,et al. Study on rock–breaking mechanism of axe–shaped PDC cutter[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2021,205:108922.

[17] WANG Xinrui,ZHANG Hui,DONG Zhuoxin,et al. Characterizing rock–breaking performance of PDC cutters via stability metrics and energy consumption in FDEM simulations[J]. Scientific Reports,2024,14:24159.

[18] 居培,王传留. 弧角型PDC钻头切削齿布齿模式仿真分析[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2020,48(5):240−245

JU Pei,WANG Chuanliu. Simulation of the cutter arrangement pattern of the arc PDC drill bit[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2020,48(5):240−245

[19] 汤凤林,НЕСКОРОМНЫХ В B,宁伏龙,等. 金刚石钻进岩石破碎过程及其与规程参数关系的研究[J]. 钻探工程,2021,48(10):43−55

TANG Fenglin,НЕСКОРОМНЫХ В B,NING Fulong,et al. Research on the rock fragmentation process and its relationship with drilling parameters in diamond drilling[J]. Drilling Engineering,2021,48(10):43−55

[20] 秦承帅,孙洪斌,李利平,等. 复合冲击作用下PDC钻齿破岩过程连续–非连续数值模拟研究[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2023,51(9):109−120

QIN Chengshuai,SUN Hongbin,LI Liping,et al. Continuous and discontinuous numerical simulation of the rock breaking process of PDC drill bit under composite impact[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2023,51(9):109−120

[21] 刘维，高德利，李越，等. PDC齿主要失效形式与钻头选型方法研究[J/OL]. 金刚石与磨料磨具工程，2026：1–50 [2026-01-29]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/41.1243.TG.20260129.1355.002.

[22] 未九森,邵方源,谭紫阳,等. PDC切削齿直径对切削力的影响规律研究[J]. 石油机械,2023,51(4):8−15

WEI Jiusen,SHAO Fangyuan,TAN Ziyang,et al. Influence of PDC cutter diameter on cutting force[J]. China Petroleum Machinery,2023,51(4):8−15

[23] 邹德永,徐城凯,易杨,等. PDC钻头布齿参数与地层适应性的试验研究[J]. 天然气工业,2017,37(9):85−90

ZOU Deyong,XU Chengkai,YI Yang,et al. An experimental study on PDC bits’ cutter parameters and formation adaptability[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2017,37(9):85−90

[24] YANG Lei,LI Yumei,XI Yan,et al. Numerical investigation of rock–breaking mechanisms and influencing factors of different PDC cutters during rotary percussion drilling[J]. Geoenergy Science and Engineering,2024,241:213144.

[25] LIU Wei,WEI Jiusen,GE Yanbo,et al. New prediction method for ROP potential of shaped PDC cutters[J]. SPE Journal,2025,30(4):1670−1679.

[26] 况雨春,张明明,冯明,等. PDC齿破岩仿真模型与全钻头实验研究[J]. 地下空间与工程学报,2018,14(5):1218−1225

KUANG Yuchun,ZHANG Mingming,FENG Ming,et al. Simulation model of PDC tooth cutting rock and experimental research on the bit[J]. Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering,2018,14(5):1218−1225

[27] HE Xianqun,XU Chaoshui,PENG Kang,et al. On the critical failure mode transition depth for rock cutting with different back rake angles[J]. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology,2017,63:95−105.

[28] LIU Weiji,ZHU Xiaohua,JING Jun. The analysis of ductile–brittle failure mode transition in rock cutting[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2018,163:311−319.

[29] 刘维，高德利，未九森，等. 钻头破岩效率与对应提速策略研究[J/OL]. 石油钻探技术，2026：1–31 [2026-01-15]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/11.1763.TE.20260114.1806.004.

LIU Wei，GAO Deli，WEI Jiusen，et al. Study on rock–breaking efficiency of PDC bits and the corresponding ROP improvement strategies[J/OL]. Petroleum Drilling Techniques，2026：1–31 [2026-01-15]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/11.1763.TE.20260114.1806.004.

[30] 史怀忠,傅新康,陈振良,等. 高温高压条件下PDC钻头破碎花岗岩试验研究[J]. 石油机械,2021,49(12):1−9

SHI Huaizhong,FU Xinkang,CHEN Zhenliang,et al. Experimental study on granite broken by PDC bit under high temperature and high pressure[J]. China Petroleum Machinery,2021,49(12):1−9

[31] 祝效华,李海. PDC切削齿破岩效率数值模拟研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报,2015,23(1):182−191

ZHU Xiaohua,LI Hai. Numerical simulation on mechanical special energy of PDC cutter rock–cutting[J]. Journal of Basic Science and Engineering,2015,23(1):182−191

[32] LIU Weiji,DENG Hongxing,ZHU Xiaohua,et al. Experimental study of the rock cutting mechanism with PDC cutter under confining pressure condition[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering,2023,56(10):7377−7396.

[33] 高峰,史怀忠,黄中伟,等. 基于黏聚力单元的PDC钻头冲击破碎硬岩数值模拟[J]. 石油机械,2025,53(10):109−114

GAO Feng,SHI Huaizhong,HUANG Zhongwei,et al. Numerical simulation on impact crushing of hard rock by PDC bit based on cohesive element[J]. China Petroleum Machinery,2025,53(10):109−114

[34] 彭旭,郝世俊. 全尺寸PDC钻头复合冲击破岩机理的有限元分析[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2021,49(2):240−246

PENG Xu,HAO Shijun. Rock breaking mechanism of composite impact of full–size PDC bit based on finite element analysis[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2021,49(2):240−246

[35] 豆旭谦,姚宁平,李秀山,等. 基于单柱齿破岩过程的高压液动冲击回转钻进试验研究[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2022,50(12):170−176

DOU Xuqian,YAO Ningping,LI Xiushan,et al. Experimental study on high–pressure hydraulic percussive rotary drilling based on single–tooth rock–breaking process[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2022,50(12):170−176

[36] 王新东,武智,姚昌顺,等. 新疆油田砂砾岩水平段个性化钻头研究与试验[J]. 新疆石油天然气,2022,18(1):54−58

WANG Xindong,WU Zhi,YAO Changshun,et al. Study and test of individualized bit for the horizontal sections of glutenite in Xinjiang Oilfield[J]. Xinjiang Oil & Gas,2022,18(1):54−58

[37] 高晓亮,居培,赵建国. 煤层顶板大直径定向钻孔用双级双速PDC钻头设计及应用[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2021,49(5):272−277

GAO Xiaoliang,JU Pei,ZHAO Jianguo. Design and application of PDC bit for large diameter directional drilling of coal seam roof with double stage and double speed[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2021,49(5):272−277

[38] 王传留,金新,高晓亮,等. 硬岩PDC定向钻头优化设计及其表面增材技术研究[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2022,50(8):157−164

WANG Chuanliu,JIN Xin,GAO Xiaoliang,et al. Optimized design and surface additive technology of PDC bit for hard rock directional drilling[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2022,50(8):157−164

[39] CHEN Xuyue,GAO Deli,GUO Boyun,et al. Real–time optimization of drilling parameters based on mechanical specific energy for rotating drilling with positive displacement motor in the hard formation[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering,2016,35:686−694.

[40] 刘伟吉,张家辉,冯嘉豪,等. 基于全井机械比能模型的钻井参数优化[J]. 断块油气田,2025,32(6):1051−1056

LIU Weiji,ZHANG Jiahui,FENG Jiahao,et al. Optimization of drilling parameters based on whole well mechanical specific energy model[J]. Fault–Block Oil & Gas Field,2025,32(6):1051−1056

[41] WEI Jiusen,ZHANG Guangqing,LIU Wei,et al. Improved calculation model of mechanical specific energy based on single–cutter rock–breaking mechanism[J]. SPE Journal,2025,30(12):7414−7427.

[42] LIU Wei,DONG Hao,WEI Jiusen,et al. Optimizing the cutting efficiency of shaped polycrystalline diamond compact cutters by adjusting the cutter orientation[J]. SPE Journal,2025,30(4):1680−1693.

[43] WEI Jiusen,LIU Wei,GAO Deli. Modeling of PDC bit–rock interaction behaviors based on the analysis of dynamic rock–cutting process[J]. Geoenergy Science and Engineering,2024,239:212955.