An experimental study on the breakthrough pressure of different CO₂ phases against cap rocks for carbon storage in saline aquifers

Authors

DAN Wendong, Key Laboratory of Groundwater Resources and Environment, Ministry of Education, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China；Key Laboratory of Coast Civil Structure Safety of Ministry of Education , School of Civil Engineering, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, ChinaFollow
LI Yi, Key Laboratory of Groundwater Resources and Environment, Ministry of Education, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China；Key Laboratory of Coast Civil Structure Safety of Ministry of Education , School of Civil Engineering, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, ChinaFollow
WANG Fugang, Key Laboratory of Groundwater Resources and Environment, Ministry of Education, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, ChinaFollow
HU Zhikai, Key Laboratory of Coast Civil Structure Safety of Ministry of Education , School of Civil Engineering, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China
DIAO Yujie, Key Laboratory of Carbon Dioxide Geological Survey, Center for Hydrogeology and Environmental Geology Survey, China Geological Survey, Tianjin 300304, China
MA Xin, Key Laboratory of Carbon Dioxide Geological Survey, Center for Hydrogeology and Environmental Geology Survey, China Geological Survey, Tianjin 300304, China
LIU Ting, Key Laboratory of Carbon Dioxide Geological Survey, Center for Hydrogeology and Environmental Geology Survey, China Geological Survey, Tianjin 300304, China

Abstract

Objective CO₂ breakthrough pressure, a core parameter for characterizing the sealing performance of saline aquifers as cap rocks, holds important scientific significance and application value for ensuring the safety of CO₂ geological storage engineering and assessing its storage potential. However, there is a lack of systematic studies on the variation patterns and mechanisms of breakthrough pressure under different occurrence phases of CO₂ (supercritical, liquid, and gaseous) currently. Accordingly, universal and reliable conclusions are yet to be reached. Methods This study conducted experiments on a natural low-permeability unsaturated sandstone core. Using the step-by-step method, 13 groups of breakthrough pressure experiments were carried out under different CO₂ phases to deeply explore the variation patterns of CO₂ breakthrough pressure under these phases. Results and Conclusions The results indicate that the CO₂ phase is not directly correlated with the magnitude of the CO₂ breakthrough pressure. Under the experimental conditions of this study, the CO₂ breakthrough pressure at any phase transition point was higher than that under a single phase. Under the condition of a single CO₂ phase, the CO₂ breakthrough pressure decreased with an increase in pressure, exhibiting an exponential relationship with the latter. Pressure produced the greatest impact on the breakthrough pressure of supercritical CO₂ but posed the smallest impact on that of gaseous CO₂. The influence of pressure on CO₂ breakthrough pressure is caused by the synergistic effect of the interfacial tension of the CO₂-water system and the wettability (the contact angle) of the CO₂-water-rock system, as well as the two-phase density difference and viscosity ratio. Sensitivity analysis results show that the viscosity ratio was a significant factor affecting the CO₂ breakthrough pressure, with a total contribution rate of up to 39.9%. Analysis of the lg C_a-lg M displacement stability diagram further confirmed that viscosity acted as a dominant factor affecting the experimental results of this study. Comparison with the formation pressure data and practical application to engineering sites in basins reveal that the experimental conditions of this study are consistent with actual engineering. The results of this study serve as an important reference for accurately evaluating the storage capacity of saline aquifers and guiding target siting for CO₂ geologic geological storage.

Keywords

CO2 phase, breakthrough pressure, viscous force, CO2 geologic storage, saline aquifer

DOI

10.12363/issn.1001-1986.25.04.0247

Recommended Citation

DAN Wendong, LI Yi, WANG Fugang, et al. (2025) "An experimental study on the breakthrough pressure of different CO₂ phases against cap rocks for carbon storage in saline aquifers," Coal Geology & Exploration: Vol. 53: Iss. 10, Article 14.
DOI: 10.12363/issn.1001-1986.25.04.0247
Available at: https://cge.researchcommons.org/journal/vol53/iss10/14

Reference

[1] YAO Weizhi，LIU Liang，FUJII H，et al. Digitalization and net–zero carbon：The role of industrial robots towards carbon dioxide emission reduction[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2024，450：141820.

[2] ZHAO Jiaqi，LI Yi，LI Qi，et al. Comparative study on numerical simulation of CH₄ breakthrough pressure in unsaturated rock based on step–by–step method and continuous injection method[J]. Greenhouse Gases：Science and Technology，2025，15(2)：229−247.

[3] 武爱兵，李铱，常春，等. 不同成分盐水驱CO₂的残余气饱和度[J]. 现代地质，2014，28(5)：1061−1067.

WU Aibing，LI Yi，CHANG Chun，et al. The residual gas saturation of different components of saline flooding CO₂[J]. Geoscience，2014，28(5)：1061−1067.

[4] WANG Chen，ZHANG Siyuan，HUA Tingting，et al. CO₂ geological storage：A bibliometric analysis of research trends[J]. Heliyon，2024，10(14)：e34479.

[5] 胡智凯，李铱，索瑞厅，等. CO₂纯度对咸水层碳封存过程中残余水的影响[J]. 高校地质学报，2023，29(1)：57−65.

HU Zhikai，LI Yi，SUO Ruiting，et al. Effects of CO₂ purity on residual water during carbon sequestration in deep saline aquifers[J]. Geological Journal of China Universities，2023，29(1)：57−65.

[6] 牟瑜，王浩璠，赖学军，等. 低孔低渗咸水层CO₂封存选址评价体系：以鄂尔多斯盆地为例[J]. 煤田地质与勘探，2025，53(3)：99−112.

MOU Yu，WANG Haofan，LAI Xuejun，et al. Assessment indicator system for siting of geologic CO₂ sequestration in low–porosity and low–permeability saline aquifers：A case study of the Ordos Basin[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration，2025，53(3)：99−112.

[7] 彭玺伊，王延永，李嵩，等. 咸水层中液态与超临界CO₂运移特征和封存方式[J]. 煤田地质与勘探，2025，53(2)：99−106.

PENG Xiyi，WANG Yanyong，LI Song，et al. Migration characteristics and storage forms of liquid and supercritical CO₂ in saline aquifers[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration，2025，53(2)：99−106.

[8] 于子望，卢帅屹，白林，等. CO₂地质封存岩石力学问题研究进展[J]. 吉林大学学报(地球科学版)，2025，55(3)：930−942.

YU Ziwang，LU Shuaiyi，BAI Lin，et al. Research progress on rock mechanics of CO₂ geological sequestration[J]. Journal of Jilin University (Earth Science Edition)，2025，55(3)：930−942.

[9] LI Yi，HU Lisha，SHEN Zhaoli，et al. The effects of brine concentration on the formation of residual water[J]. Procedia Earth and Planetary Science，2013，7：496−499.

[10] LI Yi，RANJITH P G，PERERA M S A，et al. Residual water formation during the CO₂ storage process in deep saline aquifers and factors influencing it：A review[J]. Journal of CO₂ Utilization，2017，20：253−262.

[11] LI Yi，SUO Ruiting，LI Xufeng，et al. Quantitative experimental investigation of multiple P–T effects on primary drainage process during scCO₂ storage in deep saline aquifers[J]. Journal of Hydrology，2021，596：126143.

[12] 赵世宇，李铱，索瑞厅，等. 一种用于确定饱和低渗透砂岩岩心中超临界CO₂突破压力的数值方法[J]. 中国电机工程学报，2021，41(4)：1250−1257.

ZHAO Shiyu，LI Yi，SUO Ruiting，et al. A numerical method for determining supercritical CO₂ breakthrough pressure in saturated low–permeability sandstone core[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE，2021，41(4)：1250−1257.

[13] ZHAO Yan，YU Qingchun. CO₂ breakthrough pressure and permeability for unsaturated low–permeability sandstone of the Ordos Basin[J]. Journal of Hydrology，2017，550：331−342.

[14] 崔传智，李惊鸿，吴忠维，等. CO₂封存中盖层突破压力计算与分析[J]. 油气藏评价与开发，2023，13(3)：322−329.

CUI Chuanzhi，LI Jinghong，WU Zhongwei，et al. Calculation and analysis of breakthrough pressure of caprock in CO₂ storage[J]. Petroleum Reservoir Evaluation and Development，2023，13(3)：322−329.

[15] HU Zhikai，LI Yi，LI Qi，et al. A numerical simulation study of temperature and pressure effects on the breakthrough pressure of CO₂ in unsaturated low–permeability rock core[J]. Acta Geologica Sinica (English Edition)，2023，97(3)：911−924.

[16] LI Yi，LYU Lei，MING Liang，et al. Quantitative investigation of phase characteristic effects on CO₂ breakthrough pressures in unsaturated low–permeability sandstone[J]. Journal of Hydrology，2022，609：127780.

[17] 赵世宇，李铱，明亮，等. 温压条件对非饱和低渗透砂岩中CH₄突破压力影响的实验研究[J]. 地质科技通报，2021，40(3)：132−139.

ZHAO Shiyu，LI Yi，MING Liang，et al. Experimental study on the effect of temperature and pressure on CH₄ breakthrough pressure in unsaturated low–permeability sandstone[J]. Bulletin of Geological Science and Technology，2021，40(3)：132−139.

[18] ZHOU Xiaoxiao，LYU Xiuxiang，QUAN Han，et al. Influence factors and an evaluation method about breakthrough pressure of carbonate rocks：An experimental study on the Ordovician of carbonate rock from the Kalpin area，Tarim Basin，China[J]. Marine and Petroleum Geology，2019，104：313−330.

[19] WU Tong，PAN Zhejun，CONNELL L D，et al. Gas breakthrough pressure of tight rocks：A review of experimental methods and data[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering，2020，81：103408.

[20] ESPINOZA D N，SANTAMARINA J C. CO₂ breakthrough：Caprock sealing efficiency and integrity for carbon geological storage[J]. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control，2017，66：218−229.

[21] LI Yi，YU Qingchun. Rock–core scale modeling of initial water saturation effects on CO₂ breakthrough pressure in CO₂ geo–sequestration[J]. Journal of Hydrology，2020，580：124234.

[22] ZHENG Xiaojin，ESPINOZA D N. Multiphase CO₂–brine transport properties of synthetic fault gouge[J]. Marine and Petroleum Geology，2021，129：105054.

[23] CHEN Bowen，LI Qi，TAN Yongsheng，et al. Experimental measurements and characterization models of caprock breakthrough pressure for CO₂ geological storage[J]. Earth–Science Reviews，2024，252：104732.

[24] BACHU S. Sequestration of CO₂ in geological media：Criteria and approach for site selection in response to climate change[J]. Energy Conversion and Management，2000，41(9)：953−970.

[25] ESPINOZA D N，SANTAMARINA J C. Water–CO₂–mineral systems：Interfacial tension，contact angle，and diffusion–implications to CO₂ geological storage[J]. Water Resources Research，2010，46：W07537.

[26] LI Yi，ZHAO Jiaqi，SUO Ruiting，et al. Formation mechanisms of residual water in CO₂–water–rock systems：Effects of the CO₂ phase[J]. Journal of Supercritical Fluids，2024，211：106318.

[27] SARAJI S，PIRI M，GOUAL L. The effects of SO₂ contamination，brine salinity，pressure，and temperature on dynamic contact angles and interfacial tension of supercritical CO₂/brine/quartz systems[J]. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control，2014，28：147−155.

[28] AL–ZAIDI E，EDLMANN K，FAN Xianfeng. Gaseous CO₂ behaviour during water displacement in a sandstone core sample[J]. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control，2019，80：32−42.

[29] 李铱，李旭峰，沈照理，等. CO₂地质封存室内实验中盐水种类对残余水形成的影响[J]. 地学前缘，2015，22(4)：312−319.

LI Yi，LI Xufeng，SHEN Zhaoli，et al. The effects of brine species on the formation of residual water in laboratory experiments of CO₂ geological storage[J]. Earth Science Frontiers，2015，22(4)：312−319.

[30] IGLAUER S，MATHEW M S，BRESME F. Molecular dynamics computations of brine–CO₂ interfacial tensions and brine–CO₂–quartz contact angles and their effects on structural and residual trapping mechanisms in carbon geo–sequestration[J]. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science，2012，386：405−414.

[31] PEREIRA L M C，CHAPOY A，BURGASS R，et al. Study of the impact of high temperatures and pressures on the equilibrium densities and interfacial tension of the carbon dioxide/water system[J]. Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics，2016，93：404−415.

[32] LI Yi，ZHAO Jiaqi，ZHAO Shiyu，et al. Numerical simulation analysis of CH₄ breakthrough pressure in partially saturated low–permeability rock sample under multiple P–T conditions[J]. Journal of Hydrology，2023，626：130331.

[33] 李铱. CO₂–盐水–岩石系统中残余水形成机制研究[D]. 北京：中国地质大学(北京)，2016.

LI Yi. Study on the formation mechanisms of residual water in CO₂–brine–rock systems[D]. Beijing：China University of Geosciences (Beijing)，2016.

[34] LI Yi，LI Xiangyang，HU Zhikai，et al. Core–flooding experiments of various concentrations of CO₂/N₂ mixture in different rocks：II. Effect of rock properties on residual water[J]. Greenhouse Gases：Science and Technology，2024，14(5)：871−886.

[35] LI Yi，WU Aibing，ZHANG Cheng，et al. The effects of quartz content on the formation of residual water in a brine–CO₂–quartz system：An experimental study[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering，2015，27：1609−1619.

[36] WANG Hongsheng，DALTON L，GUO Ruichang，et al. Application of unsupervised deep learning to image segmentation and in–situ contact angle measurements in a CO₂–water–rock system[J]. Advances in Water Resources，2023，173：104385.

[37] NHUNDURU R A E，JAHANBAKHSH A，SHAHROKHI O，et al. The impact of wettability on dynamic fluid connectivity and flow transport kinetics in porous media[J]. Water Resources Research，2022，58(6)：e2021WR030729.

[38] ISAH A，ARIF M，MAHMOUD M，et al. Influence of rock permeability and surface conditioning on carbonate wettability：A link between contact angle and Amott–index[J]. Geoenergy Science and Engineering，2023，227：211892.

[39] PAN Bin，LI Yajun，XIE Liujuan，et al. Role of fluid density on quartz wettability[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering，2019，172：511−516.

[40] YANG Xin，TANG Yanbing，LI Min，et al. Effect of shear–thinning of non–Newtonian fluid on the crossover from capillary fingering to viscous fingering in porous media[J]. Physics Letters A，2022，449：128364.

[41] 赵世宇. 温压条件对非饱和低渗砂岩中CH₄突破压力的影响[D]. 呼和浩特：内蒙古大学，2021.

ZHAO Shiyu. Study on the effect of temperature and pressure on CH₄ breakthrough pressure in unsaturated low–permeability sandstone[D]. Hohhot：Inner Mongolia University，2021.

[42] 索瑞厅，李旭峰，高鹏宇，等. 温度压力对岩心尺度CO₂–水–岩系统中残余水影响的实验研究[J]. 中国电机工程学报，2021，41(11)：3711−3721.

SUO Ruiting，LI Xufeng，GAO Pengyu，et al. Experimental study on the effects of temperature and pressure on residual water in the CO₂–H₂O–rock system of core–scale[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE，2021，41(11)：3711−3721.

[43] 高鹏宇. 温度压力对CO₂地质储存中残余水的影响及作用机制[D]. 呼和浩特：内蒙古大学，2019.

GAO Pengyu. Effects of temperature and pressure on residual water in CO₂ geological storage and its mechanism[D]. Hohhot：Inner Mongolia University，2019.

[44] 向鑫. 基于优化灰色关联度理论的矿井突水水源识别模型及应用[J]. 水利规划与设计，2025(8)：105–110

原文无英文

[45] 魏梦娣，龚志起，喇建明. 基于灰色关联度和STIRPAT的建筑人均碳排放影响因素分析[J]. 四川建材，2025，51(4)：44−47.

WEI Mengdi，GONG Zhiqi，LA Jianming. Study on the influencing factors of carbon emission per capita in buildings based on grey correlation and STIRPAT[J]. Sichuan Building Materials，2025，51(4)：44−47.

[46] LENORMAND R，TOUBOUL E，ZARCONE C. Numerical models and experiments on immiscible displacements in porous media[J]. Journal of Fluid Mechanics，1988，189：165−187.

[47] 索瑞厅. 不同岩心中CO₂相态与纯度对CO₂地质封存中残余水的影响[D]. 呼和浩特：内蒙古大学，2021.

SUO Ruiting. Effects of CO₂ phase state and purity in various rock cores on residual water in CO₂ geological storage[D]. Hohhot：Inner Mongolia University，2021.

[48] ZHANG Changyong，OOSTROM M，WIETSMA T W，et al. Influence of viscous and capillary forces on immiscible fluid displacement：Pore–scale experimental study in a water–wet micromodel demonstrating viscous and capillary fingering[J]. Energy & Fuels，2011，25(8)：3493−3505.

[49] LI Yi，YU Qingchun. The effects of brine species on the formation of residual water in a CO₂–brine system[J]. Transport in Porous Media，2014，104(3)：553−564.

[50] TSUJI T，JIANG Fei，CHRISTENSEN K T. Characterization of immiscible fluid displacement processes with various capillary numbers and viscosity ratios in 3D natural sandstone[J]. Advances in Water Resources，2016，95：3−15.

[51] JU Yang，GONG Wenbo，CHANG Wei，et al. Effects of pore characteristics on water–oil two–phase displacement in non–homogeneous pore structures：A pore–scale lattice Boltzmann model considering various fluid density ratios[J]. International Journal of Engineering Science，2020，154：103343.

[52] 陈越，杨娇娇，李雪，等. 浙东沿海典型沉积盆地CO₂地质封存潜力与试点意义分析：以长河盆地为例[J]. 海洋地质前沿，2024，40(8)：1−11.

CHEN Yue，YANG Jiaojiao，LI Xue，et al. Potential and pilot significance of CO₂ geological storage in typical sedimentary basin along east Zhejiang coast，China：A case study in Changhe Basin[J]. Marine Geology Frontiers，2024，40(8)：1−11.

[53] 肖贝，陈磊，杨皝，等. 准噶尔盆地深部咸水层CO₂地质封存适宜性及潜力评价[J]. 大庆石油地质与开发，2024，43(6)：120−127.

XIAO Bei，CHEN Lei，YANG Huang，et al. Suitability and potential evaluation of CO₂ geological storage in deep saline aquifers of Junggar Basin[J]. Petroleum Geology & Oilfield Development in Daqing，2024，43(6)：120−127.

[54] LYU Xiuxiang，WANG Yafang，YU Hongfeng，et al. Major factors affecting the closure of marine carbonate caprock and their quantitative evaluation：A case study of Ordovician rocks on the northern slope of the Tazhong uplift in the Tarim Basin，Western China[J]. Marine and Petroleum Geology，2017，83：231−245.