Underground coal gasification: Overview of field tests and suggestions for industrialization

Authors

DONG Zhen, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, ChinaFollow
CHEN Yanpeng, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
KONG Lingfeng, China National Petroleum Corporation, Beijing 100024, China; School of Petroleum Engineering, China University of Petroleum(East China), Qingdao 266580, China
WANG Feng, PetroChina Coalbed Methane Company Limited, Beijing 100028, China
CHEN Hao, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, ChinaFollow
XUE Junjie, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
ZHANG Mengyuan, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
CHEN Shanshan, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
ZHAO Yufeng, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
YU Yueyu, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083, China
GONG Wanxing, PetroChina Tuha Oilfield Company, Hami 839000, China
SUN Hongliang, PetroChina Tuha Oilfield Company, Hami 839000, China
WANG Xinggang, PetroChina Tuha Oilfield Company, Hami 839000, China

Abstract

Driven by the dual demands for achieving the goals of peak carbon dioxide emissions and carbon neutrality and for ensuring national energy security, underground coal gasification (UCG) in China is embracing a new historical development opportunity. To scientifically formulate a route for making technological breakthroughs in UCG and accelerate its industrialization, this study analyzed the history of UCG field tests, dividing UCG into three stages: UCG based on coal mines, vertical/directional wells, and horizontal wells. By exploring the underlying logic that propelled innovations in UCG technologies in different stages, this study delved into the technical and non-technical reasons for the failure of UCG industrialization and finally proposed suggestions. Key findings are as follows: (1) The UCG technology combining horizontal wells with the controlled retracting injection point (CRIP) process can effectively avoid the risks of surface subsidence and freshwater pollution caused by shallow gasification. Furthermore, this technology enjoys advantages in terms of expanding the vertical coal mining range, increasing single-well-controlled coals, improving the quality of raw gas, and ensuring continuous gasification. Hence, this technology serves as a mainstream technical route currently and in the future. (2) After the longest field test period, China has remained long in the stage of UGS based on coal mines. Although China is still in the initial stage of tests for breakthroughs in moderately deep UCG, it roughly keeps the same pace with other major coal-rich countries in terms of technical research and development due to the challenging technology research and low technological maturity. Therefore, China is expected to overtake these countries in the technology for UCG based on drilled wells. (3) Regarding technical reasons, limited technology applicability poses challenges in the industrialization of UCG based on coal mines and vertical wells, while low technological maturity predominantly restricts the industrialization of UGS based on horizontal wells. Consequently, long-term stable and high gas production is yet to be achieved. (4) Concerning non-technical reasons, the termination of UCG tests abroad is primarily caused by low-cost production of conventional natural gas, the influence of the shale gas revolution, public concerns about environmental pollution caused by shallow gasification, and governments' UCG policy shift. In contrast, China's UCG industrialization is principally hindered by a prolonged gap in development planning, relatively limited entities engaging in scientific research and tests, insufficient investment in scientific research, a lack of industrial support policies, and the absence of joint innovation mechanisms. This study proposed suggestions for China's UCG industrialization. In the new era, it is necessary to thoroughly identify the complexity and challenges of UCG technology. Then, great efforts should made to achieve long-term stable production with considerably high quality. It is recommended that the technological maturity should be constantly improved through synchronous scientific research and field tests. The cascade production mode featuring physical gas extraction followed by chemical gasification should be employed to avoid competition with coalbed methane production. Meanwhile, it is necessary to actively explore the utilization mode that integrates oil and gas, new energy, and coal chemical industry for elevated economic benefits. As a revolutionary production technology for artificially created gas reservoirs, UCG, after successful achievement, can provide a technical reference for the fluidization exploitation of other mineral resources and push China's unconventional technology for fossil energy development to a new level.

Keywords

underground coal gasification (UCG), moderately deep coal, gasification based on coal mines, industrialization, technical reason, industrial policy, development suggestion

DOI

10.12363/issn.1001-1986.23.09.0562

Recommended Citation

DONG Zhen, CHEN Yanpeng, KONG Lingfeng, et al. (2024) "Underground coal gasification: Overview of field tests and suggestions for industrialization," Coal Geology & Exploration: Vol. 52: Iss. 2, Article 19.
DOI: 10.12363/issn.1001-1986.23.09.0562
Available at: https://cge.researchcommons.org/journal/vol52/iss2/19

Reference

[1] 国家统计局. 中华人民共和国2022年国民经济和社会发展统计公报[EB/OL]. (2023-02-28) [2023-07-07].https：//www. gov. cn/xinwen/2023–02/28/content_5743623. htm.

[2] 中国石油集团经济技术研究院. 2022年国内外油气行业发展报告[R]. 北京：中国石油集团经济技术研究院，2023.

[3] 邹才能，陈艳鹏，孔令峰，等. 煤炭地下气化及对中国天然气发展的战略意义[J]. 石油勘探与开发，2019，46(2)：195−204.

ZOU Caineng，CHEN Yanpeng，KONG Lingfeng，et al. Underground coal gasification and its strategic significance to the development of natural gas industry in China[J]. Petroleum Exploration and Development，2019，46(2)：195−204.

[4] 孔令峰，东振，陈艳鹏，等. 基于中深层煤原位清洁转化技术构建低碳能源生态圈[J]. 天然气工业，2022，42(9)：166−175.

KONG Lingfeng，DONG Zhen，CHEN Yanpeng，et al. Construction of low–carbon energy ecosystem based on in–situ clean conversion technology of medium–deep coal[J]. Natural Gas Industry，2022，42(9)：166−175.

[5] 孔令峰，朱兴珊，展恩强，等. 深层煤炭地下气化技术与中国天然气自给能力分析[J]. 国际石油经济，2018，26(6)：85−94.

KONG Lingfeng，ZHU Xingshan，ZHAN Enqiang，et al. Suggestions on China’s natural gas self–sufficiency by deep coal underground gasification technology[J]. International Petroleum Economics，2018，26(6)：85−94.

[6] 杨震，孔令峰，孙万军，等. 油气开采企业开展深层煤炭地下气化业务的前景分析[J]. 天然气工业，2015，35(8)：99−105.

YANG Zhen，KONG Lingfeng，SUN Wanjun，et al. Prospects of underground deep–zone coal gasification performed by oil and gas production enterprises[J]. Natural Gas Industry，2015，35(8)：99−105.

[7] PERKINS G. Underground coal gasification–Part I：Field demonstrations and process performance[J]. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science，2018，67：158−187.

[8] PERKINS G. Underground coal gasification–Part II：Fundamental phenomena and modeling[J]. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science，2018，67：234−274.

[9] BHUTTO A W，BAZMI A A，ZAHEDI G. Underground coal gasification：From fundamentals to applications[J]. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science，2013，39(1)：189−214.

[10] SHAFIROVICH E，VARMA A. Underground coal gasification：A brief review of current status[J]. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research，2009，48(17)：7865−7875.

[11] KHAN M M，MMBAGA J P，SHIRAZI A S，et al. Modelling underground coal gasification：A review[J]. Energies，2015，8(11)：12603−12668.

[12] 孔令峰，赵忠勋，赵炳刚，等. 利用深层煤炭地下气化技术建设煤穴储气库的可行性研究[J]. 天然气工业，2016，36(3)：99−107.

KONG Lingfeng，ZHAO Zhongxun，ZHAO Binggang，et al. Feasibility analysis on rebuilding coal–mine gas storage by using underground coal gasification (UCG) technology[J]. Natural Gas Industry，2016，36(3)：99−107.

[13] 韩军，方惠军，喻岳钰，等. 煤炭地下气化产业与技术发展的主要问题及对策[J]. 石油科技论坛，2020，39(3)：50−59.

HAN Jun，FANG Huijun，YU Yueyu，et al. Main problems and countermeasures of underground coal gasification industrial and technological development[J]. Oil Forum，2020，39(3)：50−59.

[14] 秦勇，易同生，汪凌霞，等. 面向项目风险控制的煤炭地下气化地质条件分析[J]. 煤炭学报，2023，48(1)：290−306.

QIN Yong，YI Tongsheng，WANG Lingxia，et al. Analysis of geological conditions for risk control of UCG project[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2023，48(1)：290−306.

[15] 秦勇，易同生，杨磊，等. 中国煤炭地下气化现场试验探索历程与前景展望[J]. 煤田地质与勘探，2023，51(7)：17−25.

QIN Yong，YI Tongsheng，YANG Lei，et al. Underground coal gasification field tests in China：History and prospects[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration，2023，51(7)：17−25.

[16] 秦勇，易同生，周永锋，等. 煤炭地下气化产业政策建设困境与破局对策[J]. 煤炭学报，2023，48(6)：2498−2505.

QIN Yong，YI Tongsheng，ZHOU Yongfeng，et al. Dilemma and countermeasure of policy construction of UCG industry[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2023，48(6)：2498−2505.

[17] 梁杰，王喆，梁鲲，等. 煤炭地下气化技术进展与工程科技[J]. 煤炭学报，2020，45(1)：393−402.

LIANG Jie，WANG Zhe，LIANG Kun，et al. Progress and technology of underground coal gasification[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2020，45(1)：393−402.

[18] 梁杰. 煤炭地下气化技术进展[J]. 煤炭工程，2017，49(8)：1−4.

LIANG Jie. Development overview of underground coal gasification technology[J]. Coal Engineering，2017，49(8)：1−4.

[19] 梁杰，崔勇，王张卿，等. 煤炭地下气化炉型及工艺[J]. 煤炭科学技术，2013，41(5)：10−15.

LIANG Jie，CUI Yong，WANG Zhangqing，et al. Gasifier type and technique of underground coal gasification[J]. Coal Science and Technology，2013，41(5)：10−15.

[20] 柳少波，洪峰，梁杰. 煤炭地下气化技术及其应用前景[J]. 天然气工业，2005，25(8)：119−122.

LIU Shaobo，HONG Feng，LIANG Jie. Technology and application prospect of underground coal gasification[J]. Natural Gas Industry，2005，25(8)：119−122.

[21] 刘淑琴，张尚军，牛茂斐，等. 煤炭地下气化技术及其应用前景[J]. 地学前缘，2016，23(3)：97−102.

LIU Shuqin，ZHANG Shangjun，NIU Maofei，et al. Technology process and application prospect of underground coal gasification[J]. Earth Science Frontiers，2016，23(3)：97−102.

[22] 刘淑琴，梅霞，郭巍，等. 煤炭地下气化理论与技术研究进展[J]. 煤炭科学技术，2020，48(1)：90−99.

LIU Shuqin，MEI Xia，GUO Wei，et al. Progress of underground coal gasification theory and technology[J]. Coal Science and Technology，2020，48(1)：90−99.

[23] 刘淑琴，畅志兵，刘金昌. 深部煤炭原位气化开采关键技术及发展前景[J]. 矿业科学学报，2021，6(3)：261−270.

LIU Shuqin，CHANG Zhibing，LIU Jinchang. Key technologies and prospect for in–situ gasification mining of deep coal resources[J]. Journal of Mining Science and Technology，2021，6(3)：261−270.

[24] 许浩，陈艳鹏，辛福东，等. 煤炭地下气化面临的挑战与技术对策[J]. 煤炭科学技术，2022，50(1)：265−274.

XU Hao，CHEN Yanpeng，XIN Fudong，et al. Challenges faced by underground coal gasification and technical countermeasures[J]. Coal Science and Technology，2022，50(1)：265−274.

[25] 葛世荣. 深部煤炭化学开采技术[J]. 中国矿业大学学报，2017，46(4)：679−691.

GE Shirong. Chemical mining technology for deep coal resources[J]. Journal of China University of Mining & Technology，2017，46(4)：679−691.

[26] BLINDERMAN M S，KLIMENKO A Y. Underground coal gasification and combustion[M]. Duxford：Woodhead Publishing，2018.

[27] GREGG D W，EDGAR T F. Underground coal gasification[J]. The American Institute of Chemical Engineers，1978，24(5)：753−781.

[28] LAZARENKO S N，KREININ E V. Underground coal gasification in Kuzbass：Present and future;institute of coal[R]. Kemerovo：Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences，1994.

[29] 余力，刘淑琴. 关于煤炭地下气化新工艺LLTS–UCG实现商业化应用的思考[J]. 科技导报，2003(2)：51−54.

YU Li，LIU Shuqin. Thoughts on commercialization of new technique LLTS–UCG[J]. Science and Technology Review，2003(2)：51−54.

[30] WIATOWSKI M，KAPUSTA K，SWIADROWSKI J，et al. Technological aspects of underground coal gasification in the experimental Barbara mine[J]. Fuel，2015，159：454−462.

[31] MOCEK P，PIESZCZEK M，SWIADROWSKI J，et al. Pilot–scale underground coal gasification (UCG) experiment in an operating mine“Wieczorek”in Poland[J]. Energy，2016，111：313−321.

[32] JIANG Liangliang，CHEN Zhangxin，ALI S M F. Modelling of reverse combustion linking in underground coal gasification[J]. Fuel，2017，207：302−311.

[33] BURTON E，RIEDMANN J，UPADHYE R. Best practices in underground coal gasification[R]. San Francisco：Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory，2006.

[34] CAMP D W. A review of underground coal gasification research and development in the United States[R]. San Francisco：Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory，2017.

[35] YANG Dongmin，KOUKOUZAS N，GREEN M，et al. Recent development on underground coal gasification and subsequent CO₂ storage[J]. Journal of the Energy Institute，2016，89(4)：469−484.

[36] HILL R W，SHANNON M J. Controlled retracting injection point (CRIP) system：A modified–stream method for in situ coal gasification[R]. Berkeley：Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory，1981.

[37] RANADE V，MAHAJANI S，SAMDANI G. Computational modeling of underground coal gasification[M]. Boca Raton：CRC Press，2019.

[38] STEVE DENNIS D. Rocky Mountain 1 underground coal gasification test project Hanna，Wyoming[R]. Washington：Washington Group International，2006.

[39] GREEN M B. Underground coal gasifications：A joint European trial in Spain[R]. London：Department of Trade and Industry Technology (DTI)，1999.

[40] PIRARD J P，BRASSEUR A，COEME A，et al. Results of the tracer tests during the El Tremedal underground coal gasification at great depth[J]. Fuel，2000，79(5)：471−478.

[41] GREEN M. Recent developments and current position of underground coal gasification[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part A. Journal of Power and Energy，2018，232(1)：39−46.

[42] 张金华，张梦媛，陈艳鹏，等. 煤炭地下气化现场试验进展与启示[J]. 煤炭科学技术，2022，50(2)：213−222.

ZHANG Jinhua，ZHANG Mengyuan，CHEN Yanpeng，et al. Progresses and revelation of underground coal gasification field test[J]. Coal Science and Technology，2022，50(2)：213−222.

[43] MALLETT C W. Environmental controls for underground coal gasification[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers，Part A：Journal of Power and Energy，2018，232(1)：47–55.

[44] Alberta Energy Regulator. AER investigation report：Swan Hills synfuels ltd well blowout October 10，2011[R]. Calgary：Alberta Energy Regulator，2014.

[45] KASANI H A，CHALATURNYK R J. Coupled reservoir and geomechanical simulation for a deep underground coal gasification project[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering，2017，37：487−501.

[46] INNOVATES A. Final report of Swan Hills underground coal gasification technology research and development project[R]. Calgary：Alberta Innovates，2012.

[47] 孔令峰，张军贤，李华启，等. 我国中深层煤炭地下气化商业化路径[J]. 天然气工业，2020，40(4)：156−165.

KONG Lingfeng，ZHANG Junxian，LI Huaqi，et al. Commercialization path of medium–deep underground coal gasification in China[J]. Natural Gas Industry，2020，40(4)：156−165.

[48] 东振，任博，陈艳鹏，等. 中深层煤炭地下气化的气化腔安全宽度计算方法[J/OL]. 煤炭科学技术，2023：1–13 [2023-07-23]. DOI：10. 13199/j. cnki. cst. 2023–0444.

DONG Zhen，REN Bo，CHEN Yanpeng，et al. Calculation method of safe width of gasification cavity for medium–deep underground coal gasification[J/OL]. Coal Science and Technology，2023：1–13 [2023-07-23]. DOI：10. 13199/j. cnki. cst. 2023–0444.

[49] 张明，王世鹏. 国内外煤炭地下气化技术现状及新奥攻关进展[J]. 探矿工程(岩土钻掘工程)，2010，37(10)：14−16.

ZHANG Ming，WANG Shipeng. Technical situation of underground coal gasification in China and abroad and the study progress of ENN[J]. Exploration Engineering (Rock & Soil Drilling and Tunneling)，2010，37(10)：14−16.

[50] 韦波，李鑫，田继军，等. 国内外煤炭地下气化试验及其对新疆煤炭地下气化的启示[J]. 煤炭科技，2022，43(4)：27−35.

WEI Bo，LI Xin，TIAN Jijun，et al. Underground coal gasification trials at home and abroad and its enlightenment to Xinjiang underground coal gasification[J]. Coal Science & Technology Magazine，2022，43(4)：27−35.

[51] CAMP D W，WHITE J A. Underground coal gasification：An overview of groundwater contamination hazards and mitigation strategies[R]. San Francisco：Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory，2015.

[52] 黄赞，周瑞琦，杨焦生，等. 煤层气开发井网样式和井距优化研究：以鄂尔多斯盆地大宁区块为例[J/OL]. 煤炭科学技术，2023：1–14 [2023-07-21]. https://doi.org/10.13199/j.cnki.cst.2022–1568.

HUANG Zan，ZHOU Ruiqi，YANG Jiaosheng，et al. Study on optimization of well pattern and well spacing for CBM development：Taking Daning Block as an example[J/OL]. Coal Science and Technology，2023：1–14 [2023-07-21]. https://doi.org/10.13199/j.cnki.cst.2022–1568.

[53] 朱庆忠，李志军，李宗源，等. 复杂地质条件下煤层气高效开发实践与认识：以沁水盆地郑庄区块为例[J]. 煤田地质与勘探，2023，51(1)：131−138.

ZHU Qingzhong，LI Zhijun，LI Zongyuan，et al. Practice and cognition of efficient CBM development under complex geological conditions：A case study of Zhengzhuang Block，Qinshui Basin[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration，2023，51(1)：131−138.

[54] 孙焕泉，刘慧卿，王海涛，等. 中国稠油热采开发技术与发展方向[J]. 石油学报，2022，43(11)：1664−1674.

SUN Huanquan，LIU Huiqing，WANG Haitao，et al. Development technology and direction of thermal recovery of heavy oil in China[J]. Acta Petrolei Sinica，2022，43(11)：1664−1674.

[55] 谢和平，鞠杨，高明忠，等. 煤炭深部原位流态化开采的理论与技术体系[J]. 煤炭学报，2018，43(5)：1210−1219.

XIE Heping，JU Yang，GAO Mingzhong，et al. Theories and technologies for in–situ fluidized mining of deep underground coal resources[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2018，43(5)：1210−1219.

[56] 东振，张梦媛，陈艳鹏，等. 三塘湖–吐哈盆地富油煤赋存特征与资源潜力分析[J]. 煤炭学报，2023，48(10)：3789−3805.

DONG Zhen，ZHANG Mengyuan，CHEN Yanpeng，et al. Analysis on the occurrence characteristics and resource potential of tar–rich coal in Santanghu and Turpan–Hami Basins[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2023，48(10)：3789−3805.