Risk assessment of floor water inrush by weighted rank sum ratio based on combination weighting

Authors

YAO Hui, Hebei State Key Laboratory of Mine Disaster Prevention, North China Institute of Science and Technology, Beijing 101601, ChinaFollow
YIN Shangxian, Hebei State Key Laboratory of Mine Disaster Prevention, North China Institute of Science and Technology, Beijing 101601, China
XU Wei, Beijing Shunjian Engineering Co. Ltd., Beijing 101300, China
ZHANG Runqi, Hebei State Key Laboratory of Mine Disaster Prevention, North China Institute of Science and Technology, Beijing 101601, China
JIANG Zhiting, Hebei State Key Laboratory of Mine Disaster Prevention, North China Institute of Science and Technology, Beijing 101601, China

Abstract

Deep mining of the coal seam causes frequent water hazards in the coal mine floor. As the disadvantages of traditional water inrush risk assessment methods, such as single evaluation index and deviation of the evaluation results from reality are gradually revealed, many new assessment methods are emerging. In this paper, Donghuantuo Coal Mine, a North China type coalfield, in Hebei province is taken as the research object. The evaluation factor sets including aquifer capacity, aquifuge capacity, geological conditions and coal seam conditions are selected, and with ten evaluation factors being considered, a floor water inrush risk evaluation index system applicable to Donghuantuo Coal Mine is established. AHP and CRITIC methods are adopted to determine the subjective weight and objective weight of each index, and then the two parts are coupled to obtain the comprehensive weight. In the process, the subjective experience of experts and objective data are taken into account to ensure the comprehensiveness of weight determination. By using the weighted rank sum ratio method, an evaluation matrix is constructed. And indexes are divided into high-optimality and low-optimality according to their impacts on the evaluation objects. By ranking and calculating the WRSR value, and sorting the data based on grades, an evaluation model is formed in which four evaluation levels are determined, including safe, safer, more dangerous and dangerous. The results are displayed by using powerful spatial management and information processing function of GIS. By comparing the evaluation results with water outlet positions in the actual project, it is found that these positions are in the more dangerous area of floor water inrush. The effectiveness of the evaluation model is proved by comparing the new method with the traditional water inrush coefficient method. The research forms a new method for assessing the risk of water inrush from the coal seam floor, which enriches the existing assessment methods and provides a new thought for coal mine water control workers.

Keywords

floor water inrush, mining under pressure, weighted rank sum ratio, combination weighting

DOI

10.12363/issn.1001-1986.21.10.0556

Recommended Citation

YAO Hui, YIN Shangxian, XU Wei, et al. (2022) "Risk assessment of floor water inrush by weighted rank sum ratio based on combination weighting," Coal Geology & Exploration: Vol. 50: Iss. 6, Article 15.
DOI: 10.12363/issn.1001-1986.21.10.0556
Available at: https://cge.researchcommons.org/journal/vol50/iss6/15

Reference

[1] 尹尚先,连会青,徐斌,等. 深部带压开采:传承与创新[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2021,49(1):170−181. YIN Shangxian,LIAN Huiqing,XU Bin,et al. Deep mining under safe water pressure of aquifer:Inheritance and innovation[J]. Coal Geology&Exploration,2021,49(1):170−181.

[2] 武强,解淑寒,裴振江,等. 煤层底板突水评价的新型实用方法Ⅲ:基于GIS的ANN型脆弱性指数法应用[J]. 煤炭学报,2007,32(12):1301−1306. WU Qiang,XIE Shuhan,PEI Zhenjiang,et al. A new practical methodology of the coal floor water bursting evaluating Ⅲ:The application of ANN vulnerable index method based on GIS[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2007,32(12):1301−1306.

[3] 武强,张波,赵文德,等. 煤层底板突水评价的新型实用方法Ⅴ:基于GIS的ANN型、证据权型、Logistic回归型脆弱性指数法的比较[J]. 煤炭学报,2013,38(1):21−26. WU Qiang,ZHANG Bo,ZHAO Wende,et al. A new practical methodology of coal seam floor water burst evaluation Ⅴ:The comparison study among ANN,the weight of evidence and the logistic regression vulnerable index method based on GIS[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2013,38(1):21−26.

[4] 武强,张志龙,张生元,等. 煤层底板突水评价的新型实用方法Ⅱ:脆弱性指数法[J]. 煤炭学报,2007,32(11):1121−1126. WU Qiang,ZHANG Zhilong,ZHANG Shengyuan,et al. A new practical methodology of the coal floor water bursting evaluating Ⅱ:The vulnerable index method[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2007,32(11):1121−1126.

[5] 尹尚先,虎维岳,刘其声,等. 承压含水层上采煤突水危险性评估研究[J]. 中国矿业大学学报,2008,37(3):311−315. YIN Shangxian,HU Weiyue,LIU Qisheng,et al. Risk assessment for water inrush from confined aquifers located under coal seams[J]. Journal of China University of Mining and Technology,2008,37(3):311−315.

[6] 李忠建,魏久传,郭建斌,等. 运用突水系数法和模糊聚类法综合评价煤层底板突水危险性[J]. 矿业安全与环保,2010,37(1):24−26. LI Zhongjian,WEI Jiuchuan,GUO Jianbin,et al. Risk assessment for water inrush from coal seam floor based on water inrush coefficient and fuzzy clustering[J]. Mining Safety and Environmental Protection,2010,37(1):24−26.

[7] 赵东云,尹尚先,刘德民. 基于ANN的煤层底板突水危险性评价研究[J]. 煤炭技术,2010,29(7):68−70. ZHAO Dongyun,YIN Shangxian,LIU Demin. Study on water inrush dangerousness evalution of coal floor based on ANN[J]. Coal technology,2010,29(7):68−70.

[8] 徐维. 龙王沟煤矿底板突水危险性评价[D]. 廊坊：华北科技学院，2020.

XU Wei. Risk assessment of water inrush from Longwanggou Coal Mine floor[D]. Langfang：North China Institute of Science and Technology，2020.

[9] 施龙青,曲兴玥,韩进,等. 多模型融合评价煤层底板灰岩岩溶突水危险性[J]. 煤炭学报,2019,44(8):2484−2493. SHI Longqing,QU Xingyue,HAN Jin,et al. Multi–model fusion for assessing the risk of inrush of limestone karst water through mine floor[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2019,44(8):2484−2493.

[10] 田凤调. 秩和比法及其应用[M]. 北京：中国统计出版社，1993.

[11] 徐俊平. 基于加权秩和比法的高压配电网规划评价方法及应用[D]. 北京：华北电力大学，2015.

XU Junping. High voltage distribution network planning comprehensive evaluation and application research：Based on weighted rank sum ration method[D]. Beijing：North China Electric Power University，2015.

[12] 苗继承. 基于加权秩和比法的汽车物流服务商选择方法研究[D]. 西安：长安大学，2010.

MIAO Jicheng. A study on selective methods of automotive logistics service providers based on the WRSR [D]. Xi’an：Chang’an University，2010.

[13] 武强,张志龙,马积福. 煤层底板突水评价的新型实用方法Ⅰ:主控指标体系的建设[J]. 煤炭学报,2007,32(1):42−47. WU Qiang,ZHANG Zhilong,MA Jifu. A new practical methodology of the coal floor water bursting evaluating Ⅰ:The master controlling index system construction[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2007,32(1):42−47.

[14] 张晓亮. 熵权耦合层次分析赋权在煤层底板突水评价中的应用[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2017,45(3):91−95. ZHANG Xiaoliang. Application of entropy weight method and analytic hierarchy process in evaluation of water inrush from coal seam floor[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2017,45(3):91−95.

[15] 刘泽威,刘其声,刘洋. 煤层底板隐伏断层分类及突水防治措施[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2020,48(2):141−146. LIU Zewei,LIU Qisheng,LIU Yang. Classification of hidden faults in coal seam floor and measures for water inrush prevention[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2020,48(2):141−146.

[16] 邱梅,施龙青,滕超,等. 赵官井田10煤层底板突水危险性评价[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2015,43(3):61−65. QIU Mei,SHI Longqing,TENG Chao,et al. Evaluation of water inrush risk for No.10 coal seam floor of Zhaoguan mine field[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2015,43(3):61−65.

[17] 朱晓华. 地理空间信息的分形与分维[M]. 北京：测绘出版社，2007.

[18] 尹尚先,吴志远. 钱家营井田构造复杂程度定量评价[J]. 煤矿安全,2019,50(5):218−221. YIN Shangxian,WU Zhiyuan. Quantitative evaluation of structural complexity of Qianjiaying mine field[J]. Safety in Coal Mines,2019,50(5):218−221.

[19] 钱鸣高，石平五，许家林. 矿山压力与岩层控制[M]. 徐州：中国矿业大学出版社，2010.

[20] 李江华，许延春，谢小锋，等. 采高对煤层底板破坏深度的影响[J]. 煤炭学报，2015，40(增刊2)：303–310.

LI Jianghua，XU Yanchun，XIE Xiaofeng，et al. Influence of mining height on coal seam floor failure depth[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，205，40(Sup.2)：303–310.

[21] 魏久传,许玉阳,谢道雷,等. 基于距离函数组合赋权法的突水危险性评价[J]. 中国矿业,2021,30(4):162−167. WEI Jiuchuan,XU Yuyang,XIE Daolei,et al. The risk assessment of water bursting based on combination rule of distance function[J]. China Mining Magazine,2021,30(4):162−167.