Numerical simulations of the effects of bedding planes on hydraulic fracture propagation law in oil shale

Authors

LI Yanwei, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, ChinaFollow
ZHU Chaofan, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, China
ZENG Yijian, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, China
SHUI Haoche, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, China
FAN Cunhan, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, China
GUO Wei, College of Construction Engineering, Jilin University, Changchun 130026, China; National-Local Joint Engineering Laboratory of In-situ Conversion, Drilling and Exploitation Technology for Oil Shale, Changchun 130026, China; Provincial and Ministerial Co-construction of Collaborative Innovation Center for Shale Oil & Gas Exploration and Development, Changchun 130026, China; Key Lab of Ministry of Natural Resources for Drilling and Exploitation Technology in Complex Conditions, Changchun 130026, ChinaFollow

Abstract

Hydraulic fracturing serves as a major technical means for the exploitation of oil shale reservoirs presently, and the hydraulic fracture morphology in oil shales is primarily affected by differences in the characteristics of bedding planes. However, current studies mostly focus on the influence of the developmental degree of bedding planes on fracture propagation, overlooking the effects of the bedding plane thickness itself on hydraulic fracture propagation. This study delves into the oil shale in the Xunyi area, Ordos Basin. Based on the theory of linear elastic fracture mechanics, this study developed a stress-damage-seepage model of hydraulic fracture propagation. Using the global numerical simulation method termed finite element method-cohesive zone method (FEM-CZM), this study analyzed the effects of the in-situ stress field and bedding planes’ thickness and spacing on hydraulic fracture propagation, followed by comparing fractures’ failure type and length and the area connected by bedding planes under different influencing factors. Key findings of this study are as follows: (1) The thickness of bedding planes affects their capacity to intercept hydraulic fractures. A large thickness will lead to a strong tendency of fracture propagation along laminae planes, thus inducing tensile failure. Accordingly, long fractures and a large area connected by bedding planes will be formed. (2) The bedding plane spacing affects the time for hydraulic fractures to reach bedding planes. In the case of a small spacing, hydraulic fractures will directly penetrate bedding planes. The spacing will increase the resistance to fracture propagation. A larger bedding plane spacing is associated with longer fractures and a larger area connected by bedding planes due to tensile failure. (3) the in-situ stress field determines the direction of the hydraulic fracture propagation. In the case of a large vertical in-situ stress difference, the vertical stress will compact bedding planes. As a result, hydraulic fractures are more prone to penetrate bedding planes. When the vertical in-situ stress difference is small, hydraulic fractures will bend and branch in the process of propagation on bedding planes, leading to increased fracture length and area connected by bedding planes. Based on these findings, it is recommended that hydraulic fracturing should be performed in areas with large thicknesses and spacings of bedding planes and a small vertical stress field, which are more favorable for the formation of efficient seepage and heat transfer channels. This study can provide guidance for the hydraulic fracturing construction for oil shale in the Xunyi area.

Keywords

oil shale, hydraulic fracturing, bedding plane thickness, bedding plane spacing, in-situ stress, numerical simulation, fracture propagation law, Ordos Basin

DOI

10.12363/issn.1001-1986.23.07.0397

Recommended Citation

LI Yanwei, ZHU Chaofan, ZENG Yijian, et al. (2023) "Numerical simulations of the effects of bedding planes on hydraulic fracture propagation law in oil shale," Coal Geology & Exploration: Vol. 51: Iss. 11, Article 6.
DOI: 10.12363/issn.1001-1986.23.07.0397
Available at: https://cge.researchcommons.org/journal/vol51/iss11/6

Reference

[1] 刘招君，杨虎林，董清水，等. 中国油页岩[M]. 北京：石油工业出版社，2009.

[2] 孙友宏,郭威,邓孙华. 油页岩地下原位转化与钻采技术现状及发展趋势[J]. 钻探工程,2021,48(1):57−67.

SUN Youhong,GUO Wei,DENG Sunhua. The status and development trend of in–situ conversion and drilling exploitation technology for oil shale[J]. Drilling Engineering,2021,48(1):57−67.

[3] GUO Wei,SHUI Haoche,LIU Zhao,et al. Reliability analysis of elastic graphite packer in heat injection well during oil shale in–situ conversion[J]. Advances in Geo–Energy Research,2023,7(1):28−38.

[4] 白文翔,孙友宏,郭威,等. 吉林农安油页岩地下原位裂解先导试验工程[J]. 探矿工程(岩土钻掘工程),2017,44(增刊1):182−187.

BAI Wenxiang,SUN Youhong,GUO Wei,et al. Pilot test project of oil shale in–situ pyrolysis in Nong’an of Jilin[J]. Exploration Engineering (Rock & Soil Drilling and Tunneling),2017,44(Sup.1):182−187.

[5] 杨典森,周云,周再乐. 含界面储层水力压裂试验与数值模拟研究进展[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报,2022,41(9):1771−1794.

YANG Diansen,ZHOU Yun,ZHOU Zaile. A review of experimental and numerical simulation of hydraulic fracturing in reservoirs with interfaces[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,2022,41(9):1771−1794.

[6] 杨帆,梅文博,李亮,等. 薄互层致密砂岩水力压裂裂缝扩展特征研究[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2023,51(7):61−71.

YANG Fan,MEI Wenbo,LI Liang,et al. Propagation of hydraulic fractures in thin interbedded tight sandstones[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2023,51(7):61−71.

[7] ZHANG Jun,LI Yuwei,PAN Yishan,et al. Experiments and analysis on the influence of multiple closed cemented natural fractures on hydraulic fracture propagation in a tight sandstone reservoir[J]. Engineering Geology,2020,281:105981.

[8] 孙可明,张树翠,辛利伟. 页岩气储层层理方向对水力压裂裂纹扩展的影响[J]. 天然气工业,2016,36(2):45−51.

SUN Keming,ZHANG Shucui,XIN Liwei. Impacts of bedding directions of shale gas reservoirs on hydraulically induced crack propagation[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2016,36(2):45−51.

[9] 衡帅,杨春和,郭印同,等. 层理对页岩水力裂缝扩展的影响研究[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报,2015,34(2):228−237.

HENG Shuai,YANG Chunhe,GUO Yintong,et al. Influence of bedding planes on hydraulic fracture propagation in shale formations[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,2015,34(2):228−237.

[10] ZHANG Ruxin,HOU Bing,HAN Huifen,et al. Experimental investigation on fracture morphology in laminated shale formation by hydraulic fracturing[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2019,177:442−451.

[11] 李全贵,武晓斌,胡千庭,等. 含结构面相似材料水力裂缝演化的实验研究[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2022,50(8):45−53.

LI Quangui,WU Xiaobin,HU Qianting,et al. Experimental study of hydraulic fracture evolution with materials similar to the structural plane[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2022,50(8):45−53.

[12] 朱颖. 油页岩层理对其力学特性及裂缝起裂与扩展的影响研究[D]. 长春：吉林大学，2022.

ZHU Ying. Study on the influence of oil shale bedding planes on its mechanical properties，fracture initiation and extension[D]. Changchun：Jilin University，2022.

[13] LI Yang,LIU Wei,DENG Jingen,et al. A 2D explicit numerical scheme–based pore pressure cohesive zone model for simulating hydraulic fracture propagation in naturally fractured formation[J]. Energy Science & Engineering,2019,7(5):1527−1543.

[14] 罗垚,孔辉,徐克山,等. 砂泥岩储层水力裂缝穿层规律数值模拟[J]. 新疆石油天然气,2023,19(1):49−56.

LUO Yao,KONG Hui,XU Keshan,et al. Numerical simulation for vertical propagation pattern of hydraulic fractures in sand–shale interbedded reservoirs[J]. Xinjiang Oil & Gas,2023,19(1):49−56.

[15] SUO Yu,SU Xianheng,WANG Zijian,et al. A study of inter−stratum propagation of hydraulic fracture of sandstone−shale interbedded shale oil[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics,2022,275:108858.

[16] 李浩哲,姜在炳,舒建生,等. 水力裂缝在煤岩界面处穿层扩展规律的数值模拟[J]. 煤田地质与勘探,2020,48(2):106−113.

LI Haozhe,JIANG Zaibing,SHU Jiansheng,et al. Numerical simulation of layer–crossing propagation behavior of hydraulic fractures at coal–rock interface[J]. Coal Geology & Exploration,2020,48(2):106−113.

[17] CHEN Zuorong,BUNGER A P,ZHANG Xi,et al. Cohesive zone finite element–based modeling of hydraulic fractures[J]. Acta Mechanica Solida Sinica,2009,22(5):443−452.

[18] ZHAI Lianghao,ZHANG Han,PAN Dongbin,et al. Optimisation of hydraulic fracturing parameters based on cohesive zone method in oil shale reservoir with random distribution of weak planes[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering,2020,75:103130.

[19] SUO Yu,DONG Muyu,WANG Zijian,et al. Characteristics of mixed–mode Ⅰ–Ⅱ fracture of bedding mud shale based on discrete element method[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2022,219:111135.

[20] 周彤,王海波,李凤霞,等. 层理发育的页岩气储集层压裂裂缝扩展模拟[J]. 石油勘探与开发,2020,47(5):1039−1051.

ZHOU Tong,WANG Haibo,LI Fengxia,et al. Numerical simulation of hydraulic fracture propagation in laminated shale reservoirs[J]. Petroleum Exploration and Development,2020,47(5):1039−1051.

[21] 张丰收,吴建发,黄浩勇,等. 提高深层页岩裂缝扩展复杂程度的工艺参数优化[J]. 天然气工业,2021,41(1):125−135.

ZHANG Fengshou,WU Jianfa,HUANG Haoyong,et al. Technological parameter optimization for improving the complexity of hydraulic fractures in deep shale reservoirs[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2021,41(1):125−135.

[22] 路千里,张航,郭建春,等. 基于相场法的水力裂缝扩展模拟技术现状及展望[J]. 天然气工业,2023,43(3):59−68.

LU Qianli,ZHANG Hang,GUO Jianchun,et al. Status and prospect of hydraulic fracture propagation simulation based on phase field method[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2023,43(3):59−68.

[23] 周彤,陈铭,张士诚,等. 非均匀应力场影响下的裂缝扩展模拟及投球暂堵优化[J]. 天然气工业,2020,40(3):82−91.

ZHOU Tong,CHEN Ming,ZHANG Shicheng,et al. Simulation of fracture propagation and optimization of ball–sealer in–stage diversion under the effect of heterogeneous stress field[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2020,40(3):82−91.

[24] 段立志,马中豪,杜武刚,等. 鄂尔多斯盆地南缘彬县–旬邑地区三叠系延长组长7油页岩地质特征[J]. 陕西地质,2022,40(1):18−22.

DUAN Lizhi,MA Zhonghao,DU Wugang,et al. Geology of shale oil occurring in Chang7 of the Triassic Yanchang Formation in Binxian–Yijun area at the south margin of the Ordos Basin[J]. Geology of Shaanxi,2022,40(1):18−22.

[25] 武富礼,李文厚,李玉宏,等. 鄂尔多斯盆地上三叠统延长组三角洲沉积及演化[J]. 古地理学报,2004,6(3):307−315.

WU Fuli,LI Wenhou,LI Yuhong,et al. Delta sediments and evolution of the Yanchang Formation of Upper Triassic in Ordos Basin[J]. Journal of Palaeogeography,2004,6(3):307−315.

[26] 马中豪,陈清石,赵平甲,等. 彬县–旬邑地区油页岩开采地质条件分析[J]. 陕西地质,2016,34(2):27−31.

MA Zhonghao,CHEN Qingshi,ZHAO Pingjia,et al. Mining geological conditions of oil shale in Binxian–Xunyi area[J]. Geology of Shaanxi,2016,34(2):27−31.

[27] 昌燕,刘人和,拜文华,等. 鄂尔多斯盆地南部三叠系油页岩地质特征及富集规律[J]. 中国石油勘探,2012,17(2):74−78.

CHANG Yan,LIU Renhe,BAI Wenhua,et al. Geologic characteristic and regular pattern of Triassic oil shale south of Ordos Basin[J]. China Petroleum Exploration,2012,17(2):74−78.

[28] 潘林华，王海波，魏娟明，等. ABAQUS在水力压裂模拟中的应用[M]. 北京：中国石化出版社，2021.

[29] 翟梁皓. 油页岩水平井射孔完井水力压裂裂缝起裂与扩展机理研究[D]. 长春：吉林大学，2021.

ZHAI Lianghao. Study on the initiation and extension mechanism of hydraulic fracturing in the perforated oil shale horizontal well[D]. Changchun：Jilin University，2021.

[30] 潘林华,张士诚,张劲,等. 基于流–固耦合的压裂裂缝形态影响因素分析[J]. 西安石油大学学报(自然科学版),2012,27(3):76−80.

PAN Linhua,ZHANG Shicheng,ZHANG Jin,et al. Analysis of factors influencing the shape of hydraulic fracturing fracture based on fluid–solid coupling[J]. Journal of Xi’an Shiyou University (Natural Science Edition),2012,27(3):76−80.

[31] 位云生,林铁军,于浩,等. 基于嵌入黏聚单元法的页岩储层压裂缝网扩展规律[J]. 天然气工业,2022,42(10):74−83.

WEI Yunsheng,LIN Tiejun,YU Hao,et al. Propagation law of fracture network in shale reservoirs based on the embeded cohesive unit method[J]. Natural Gas Industry,2022,42(10):74−83.

[32] 王永炜,李荣西,杨全枝,等. 鄂尔多斯盆地陆相中生界页岩气储层井壁失稳机理研究[J]. 油气藏评价与开发,2017,7(2):78−82.

WANG Yongwei,LI Rongxi,YANG Quanzhi,et al. Research on borehole wall instability mechanism of Mesozoic shale gas reservoir in Ordos Basin[J]. Reservoir Evaluation and Development,2017,7(2):78−82.

[33] ZHU Ying,LIU Kunyan,ZHONG Xiuping,et al. Experimental investigation on the anisotropic behaviors induced by bedding planes in mechanical properties of Ma’quan Oil Shale[J]. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering,2021,47(9):11385−11403.

[34] 孙可明,冀洪杰,张树翠. 页岩层理方位及强度对水力压裂的影响[J]. 实验力学,2020,35(2):343−348.

SUN Keming,JI Hongjie,ZHANG Shucui. Influence of bedding azimuth and strength on hydraulic fracturing in shale[J]. Journal of Experimental Mechanics,2020,35(2):343−348.

[35] 侯冰,陈勉,李志猛,等. 页岩储集层水力裂缝网络扩展规模评价方法[J]. 石油勘探与开发,2014,41(6):763−768.

HOU Bing,CHEN Mian,LI Zhimeng,et al. Propagation area evaluation of hydraulic fracture networks in shale gas reservoirs[J]. Petroleum Exploration and Development,2014,41(6):763−768.